Here we go again.
Even though Israel's National Union has a lot of religious supporters/voters, it's not a "religious party." It's a patriotic, Jewish Nationalist political party open to Jews of various religious observance. Many of its religious supporters, like myself, consider that its main attraction. We're not supporters of the NRP. Speaking for myself, during the forty years I've lived in Israel, I've never voted for a religious party. I vote politics, not religion.
When we fist made aliyah in 1970, Menachem Begin's Herut Party still had its own internal elections. Then it joined with the Liberals for "GaHaL." Over the years more parties joined until it became the Likud, and then after Begin's gift of the Sinai to Sadat, I supported T'chiya. After T'chiya got insufficient votes, I've had a tough time deciding whom to vote for. I finally settled on on Moledet and then HaTikvah/National Union (HaIchud HaLeumi.)
A couple of elections ago, they combined with the NRP, National Religious Party in a very badly negotiated deal. Even though most of the potential voters wanted NU, the NRP swallowed them up. I went to a meeting of activists for the joint party. It was in a NRP building; all the speakers were NRP spouting NRP tactics and ideology. My friends and I looked at each other in horror. It was like a nightmare episode of the Twilight Zone.
That partnership broke up, thank G-d. Then the NRP changed its name, but it's still at the same place, the same people spouting the same tired and failing ideology.
Unfortunately, although the National Union may be rich with academics, intellectuals and professors, but they're not very good at real politics. Again there's talk about joining up with the NRP. Gevalt! Will they ever learn?
3 comments:
Wouldn't it be better if all the partys supporting Eretz Israel were together ???
While I agree that the NPR is not so good, if they could make a true arrangements with the ichoud and everyone which agree that Israel has to go on building and strenghtening jewish-zionist identity, we would have a great party which could easily make himself heard.
First together on the important matters - only then each one advocating its ideas.
Not the other way.
Amihai, in theory you're right, but this is being promoted as "national religious parties uniting." A different kettle of soup.
Shalom!
Do we have to go through this, again? The last time the NU bailed out the NRP they experienced a collective net loss of Knesset seats. And then, as Batya wrote, the NRP unfortunately dominated. NU should absolutely not join with the NRP - sorry Jewish Home party. (That's a strange name for a party willing to kick Jews out of their Jewish homes in the Jewish homeland.) The situation is much better when the two parties are independent and can join forces as needed. As if the Jewish Home ever has much to contribute; they're as wishy-washy as the NRP was.
Amihai, you have nice ideas, but the political situation in Israel isn't ready for them yet.
Post a Comment