A Jewish Mother's Guide to End Times
August 13, 2007
Ellen W. Horowitz
"No weapon engineered against you will succeed..."
Isaiah 54:17
The above words from this past week' s Haftara are comforting for a mother who sits in a leaderless country run by lunatics; with Iranian-backed Syria literally looming on my horizon and my sons assigned to combat units. America' s liberty crusade through the Middle East has just been turned into a shop-' til-you-drop arms extravaganza for peace, with headlines blaring: "U.S. military deals with Mideast promote stability". There is talk of imminent war, but our army is preoccupied with desecrating the city of our forefathers (Hebron); while those affected are so pained as to blaspheme our army. The Jewish unity needed to ensure victory, security and sanity seems aeons away. Nu? So what else is new?
Some warn of global warming and others of nuclear winter. Through it all, I hope and pray that my family will remain firmly planted on the ever-shifting Syrian-African rift. Armageddon is not on my mind - but Redemption always is.
I believe the words of the Prophets are true, but as a Jew I know that whereas good prophecies will be actualized, the bad ones can be overturned by human endeavors. I also know that battles can be fought in the Heavens, rather than on earth. I anticipate miracles, and yet I' ve got a few gerrycans of water and some extra blankets stored in the corner - just in case.
"Bible thumping" is something I do two weeks before Pesach - when I clean my book shelves in search of random crumbs. And "Doomsday" is what my youngest kid will face if he brings one more stray cat into this house.
"Tribulation" is what this mother went through two weeks ago as I tried to keep my children, the goats, dogs, cats, chickens, birds, and rabbits cool through an incredible heat wave. And "rapture" is what I felt when the temperature broke, leaving me - and a stressed-out air conditioner - alone.
But it' s when I' m alone that domestic and international difficulties never fail to invade my bliss. As a creative religious woman, living in the Holy Land, I confess that I' ve toyed with numerous spiritual scenarios, and pondered various political, and military options. But never have I ever entertained thoughts of a biblically based Christian Jewish merger against Islam. I¹m grateful that I' ve remained fairly lucid despite the chaos ( I' m afraid, with regards to this issue, many have not).
It wasn' t long ago that a person could have gone through an entire lifetime without ever having heard of the term "eschatology". "Judeo -Christian" was a term used to describe a cultural tradition within the framework of Western civilization - it was not a religion. And what exactly is "Islamo-Fascism", if not a newfangled term for an ancient problem called Amalek?
A corrupted fusing of faiths, ideology and political interests has produced some incredibly mutant relationships - born in sin - which have infringed upon the independent belief systems of Judaism, Islam, and Christianity. These hybrid hydras have smashed all that is sacred by trespassing spiritual, personal, political, cultural, and academic boundaries. A devastating precedent with unimaginable consequences has been set in motion.
Shimon Erem, a retired Israeli general, is now described as "an early mobilizer of Judeo-Christian anti-Islamo fascism" who feels compelled to warn the U.S. "that it must quickly end its indifference before it ceases to be a society of Christian ideals"? (You won¹t find that stuff in the annals of IDF protocol.)
Rabbi MK Benny Elon broke all historic Jewish precedent by appealing to missionary leaders to convert Muslims to Christianity, and by then proceeding to invite missionaries to become and integral part of the Jewish State' s political process?
Israeli academic and Director of the NGO The Jerusalem Summit, Dr. Dmitry Radyshevsky, calls for a Christian restoration of Europe, and for Christians and Jews to unite "politically and spiritually" in the face of radical Islam. He believes that "Jews and Christians are one tree, with the Jews forming the roots and the Christians the branches..."
In a recent Jerusalem Post article, Rabbi Shlomo Riskin ran roughshod over his revered rebbe¹s staunch position opposing interfaith theological dialogue. Perhaps Rabbi Riskin was unaware that some of those evangelical leaders which he singled out for praise are actively promoting a Messianic Jewish (Hebrew-Christian) restoration in Israel. And I believe his understanding of the concept of theological grafting - which deeply touched him - may be incomplete.
I' ll go out on a limb (no pun intended ) and suggest that not only does the cultish metaphor of a grafted Judeo-Christian olive tree constitute a prohibited union; but that any Jew who adheres to, advocates, or entertains this belief is dabbling with avodah zarah (literally, "strange worship").
You can delve into Rambam, consult with your Rav, or simply read the following quote found on the website of the youth division of the ICEJ (International Christian Embassy), in order to understand just how forbidden this concept is for Jews:
Ephesians 3 vs. 6 "This mystery is that through the gospel the Gentiles are heirs together with Israel, members together of one body, and sharers together in the promise in Christ Jesus."
http://www.grafted.org/purpose.html
When Islamic Jihadi meets Christian crusader over the future of the Land of Israel, and the amen choir is made up of religious Zionists, Knesset members, and sundry Jewish national leaders; where will that leave concerned Jews who may not be Torah literate or textbook Zionists, but who do possess beating Jewish hearts, a natural aversion to alien theology, and an overwhelming sense of terrestrial responsibility? Do we just dismiss them as godless liberals and saw off that branch in order to make room for faithful Christians? Grafting 50 million plus rapture-ready evangelicals onto the far right branches of our now lopsided tree means we stand to lose a few good roots - and lose ourselves when that tree topples.
And what about the rest of the forest - meaning the rest of humanity?
There was a time when "G-d fearing" was associated with responsibility, accountability and foresight. The ability to belt out Biblical verses verbatim and creatively interpret prophetic writings was not a prerequisite to walking with G-d or being a great political leader.
Perhaps the most disappointing aspect of our current voluntary liaison with the cross, is that we stand to surrender an essential part of ourselves - and our universal role.
It was Jews who had shown the world how to temper and refine religious zeal with wisdom. We were able to transform lofty out-of-this-world concepts by bringing them into an earthly domain and channeling the inspiration into concrete, productive ethical, responsible and compassionate behavior and action that was universally acceptable. We never felt comfortable with the gushing hallelujah crowd, because, for us, religious experience had always been personal, intimate, and non-intrusive. We were to lead and win converts by sanctifying G-d' s name and serving as outstanding individual and collective examples.
At the end of the day ( as opposed to "the end of days "), Israel' s Left will have to foot the bill for initiating Oslo and the physical and emotional upheaval that ensued. However, the national Zionist camp could have it worse. In our desperation and political isolation we have knowingly forged a forbidden relationship and have initiated and implemented programs which caused spiritual destruction and gross erosion of the fences which were built around the Torah.
In an historic Biblical reversal it seems we have tried to sell our birthright to some clean-shaven, faithful preachers in exchange for the opportunity to rake in some badly needed tourist bucks, secure influence in Washington, and to pass the burden of caring for our own peoples' charitable and humanitarian needs on to ready and willing Christians. Without immediate correction, we may have to call this epic chapter in Jewish history, "Esau' s revenge ".
------
The writer lives in the Golan Heights, is a painter and the author of The Oslo Years: a Mother's Journal (available through Gefen Publishing)
10 comments:
I have long held Ellen in high regard, for her apparent devotion to Israel, to Zionism, and to her Jewish heritage and religion.
I am therefore disappointed, even saddened to see this ungracious essay coming from her.
How is Ellen harmed by 'proselytizing'--so long as that is not attempted at the point of a sword? If she is convinced of her personal religious beliefs, how do others' efforts to share their sincerely held beliefs hinder her 'walk with G-d'; why does it, evidently, so infuriate her?
Ellen wrote: "'Bible thumping' is something I do two weeks before Pesach - when I clean my book shelves...". Pesach is months away, and yet here she is, 'thumping' away.
Not that it is so much "Bible" thumping, I will grant; else, I doubt that she would have suggested, as she did, that one could have "a natural aversion to alien theology," notwithstanding they "may not be Torah literate".
That is not to mention a number of equally uninformed statements in this unwarranted, and unwelcomed diatribe.
Ellen, I really want to believe you are not a closet bigot.
David R. Wills, USA
Judaism is against the "hardsell" of any religion.
This isn't as frivilous as Coke vs Pepsi.
What was "Judaism", and where did it come from, before there was the Torah, as such? Was Abraham 'Jewish'? Or, did he keep his "religious beliefs" to himself?
What was "Judaism", and where did it come from, before Moses came along--a man who was profoundly motivated to SHARE his peculiar knowledge of God with others?
What was "Judaism", and where did it come from, before a long succession of men stepped into history, bringing with them their own "revelation" from God--which, knowledge, they were committed to share with others?
Would "Judaism" be there for you, today, had those men been indisposed to speak out (to the whole world, mind you, not just to one group of people)?
Batya, your guest author (E. Horowitz) might not have been "hardselling" the tenets of Judaism, per se; but she certainly is hardselling the idea of WALLING JUDAISM IN, AND THE WORLD OUT.
My reading of the Bible suggests that God gave his self-revelation to descendants of Abraham for the express purpose of being a light to the rest of the world; that is, the sons and daughters of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob were given a SACRED TRUST to SHARE WITH OTHERS what God had shared with them. It is unfortunate, in every case, when individuals have mouths to speak, but evidently no ears to hear....
I believe that the Truth will stand up to questioning and debate, even to opposition.
Surely, Truth (God) is neither intimidated nor enraged by a free exchange of ideas, do you suppose? Else, how will anyone who is presently believing a lie become enlightened to Truth, in the absence of the opportunity to openly communicate their own ideas?
Indeed, it is just because that
"[t]his [discussion involving the knowledge of God and differing 'religious' ideas] "...isn't as frivilous as Coke vs Pepsi", that the need for such openness is vitally important to all concerned.
'Blogging', in fact, is prima facie evidence that you (and those you host) are interested to persuade others to your point of view...no? Yet, speaking without hearing is, well, what would you call that?
As a blogger, I see my blog as my private media outlet.
There's lots more communication here than you'd have with the mainstream media.
Let's just make things clear. I wouldn't tell you how to interpert your religion, and I expect the same courtesy.
Hi David,
You and I have some very worthwhile exchanges in the past. As you have already indicated, my message and writing is directed to my people and usually concerns issues of Israel, Zionism, Jewish heritage and religion.
As I recall the correspondence we have had the past was not theological in nature. It was always honest, respectful and usually addressed issues of morality.
Proselytizing is problematic, because it implies that one party owns the truth over another. Even friendly evangelizing is invasive and offensive to the Jewish people.
Christianity is an alien theology for the Jews. The statement is not derogatory, it is simply true.
This is why I believe that those gentiles who choose to stand with Israel should take a moral/heartfelt stand. Whether the driving inspiration comes through theological scripture, personal experience, philosophical/intellectual exercise, or heartfelt meditation is not important. It need not be shared, as it has to do with one¹s personal truth and intimate relationship with G-d.
Relationships need not be built on common denominators and tolerance, they can also be built with on an understanding and respect for differences and the right to privacy.
There is no question that certain evangelical groups and individuals feel tremendous love and devotion for Israel. But this love as well as the increased interest in "Jewish roots" is tied to theology, and is fueled by eschatological aspirations and a religious obligation to spread the gospel and to promote Judeo-Christianity. Unfortunately this translates into both overt and covert missionary activity which is unacceptable for the Jew.
Respectfully,
Ellen
Ellen Horowitz = Eshet Chayil.
Ditto Batya Medad.
-- MAOZ
Ellen sure is; isn't she?
Batya, thank you for not simply cutting me off. I shall indeed respect both your religious beliefs as well as your personal blog space.
Ellen, I sincerely wish the very best for you and your family--especially in these dangerous times. I assure you that, until now, I never fully appreciated the evidently sensitive nature of what you say is a commonly shared opinion and sentiment within the Jewish religion.
Shalom.
David
David, thanks
stay in touch
Thank for understanding, David.
Ellen
Post a Comment