Thursday, February 19, 2015

The New York Times, A Careful Reading Shows Arabs Don't Want Arab Rule

We sometimes get the International New York Times, hard-copy. Today I read the most interesting article. It wasn't really new to me in a way. I work with Arabs in Yafiz-Rami Levy, Sha'ar Binyamin, and I understand very well how anxious the Arabs are to keep their jobs and not let their fellow Arabs know how much they enjoy working for Israelis and under Israeli working conditions.

This article, Desperation Drives Gazans Over a Fence and Into Israeli Prisons, is about how Gazans, who are under Arab rule remember, prefer to escape and be jailed in Israel. For them an Israeli jail is like a fancy hotel, full-board.

Read the article and tell me what you think:

EL BUREIJ, Gaza Strip — It was not much of an escape.
Moments after Ibrahim al-Awawda climbed over the nine-foot fence separating the Bureij refugee camp on Gaza’s eastern edge from Israel, he was surrounded by six Israeli soldiers. They arrested him, interrogated him and, after he spent a month in two Israeli prisons, sent him back to the poverty, death and destruction in Gaza that had led him to flee.

“I knew they would capture me,” said Ibrahim, 15, whose father was killed in an Israeli strike in 2002 and who has since lived through three wars between Israel and Gaza militants, including last summer’s bloody 50-day battle. “The war shook me,” he added. “I told myself I may find a better life. They served me good food, but later, they threw me back to Gaza.”
Ibrahim is one of an increasing number of young Palestinians from Gaza who have been caught trying to cross into Israel in the nearly six months since the latest conflagration subsided. Though he carried nothing with him, others were armed with knives or grenades.
The crossings have shaken residents on Israel’s side of the fence who are still psychologically scarred from the series of tunnel invasions by Palestinian militants that punctuated last summer’s conflict. But military officials and others see the growing phenomenon as less about terrorism than about desperation.
Several fence jumpers, and human rights workers who track their cases, compared their despondency to that of the roughly 300 Gazans who died in a September shipwreck as they were being smuggled across the Mediterranean Sea: They just wanted out, no matter the risk.
Some are shot in the process. Some are harassed upon their return by Hamas, the Islamist faction that dominates Gaza, as suspected collaborators with Israel. Still, many fantasize about finding work in Israel and see even the all-but-inevitable time behind bars as worth it, given that it comes with a monthly stipend the Palestinian Authority pays all its prisoners.
Compared with Gaza, “the prison in Israel is like a five-star hotel,” said Youssef Abbas, 21, who did stints there after crossing the border in 2010 and 2008. He said he headed toward the fence twice more in September but was turned back, once by Gaza security forces and once by a call from his fiancée.
“I was thinking of two choices: death or prison,” Mr. Abbas said. “Because there were so many problems in my life, I was so tired, I had this idea.”
The Israeli military said 84 Palestinians were arrested after hopping the fence from September to January, along with nine more in the first nine days of this month. The military would not provide comparable figures for the first half of 2014 or previous years, but it confirmed a report in the Israeli daily newspaper Haaretz that the prewar monthly average was 13, less than half the 27 arrested in November.
“It’s a slight increase,” said the Israeli military spokesman, Lt. Col. Peter Lerner, “not necessarily a game changer, as far as we’re concerned at this stage.” Still, Colonel Lerner said: “Each and every infiltration we address as a potential terrorist attack. All it takes is for one to come in with a weapon, with a grenade, with a suicide belt and so on. So that’s our concern.”
Separately, the military announced last week that it had destroyed the Israeli side of a tunnel discovered during the summer fight with Hamas.
The military wing of Hamas ran a dozen training camps last month in which 17,000 boys and men aged 15 to 21 learned to climb ropes and fire assault rifles in preparation for the next confrontation with Israel
For the Israelis living in the tiny communities near the barrier, reports of each illegal crossing are jittery reminders of last summer.
At Kibbutz Sufa, about a mile from where 13 gunmen from Gaza emerged from a tunnel on July 17 — an episode that led to Israel’s ground invasion of Gaza — “people are reliving the fear,” said Eyal Brandeis, a longtime member of the 300-person kibbutz’s emergency team and a professor of political science at Bar-Ilan University.
Rony Kissin, community manager of Kibbutz Kerem Shalom, just half a football field’s length from the fence, said that residents with permits were carrying their pistols more often than before. Children in the community are acting more violently, she said, and mothers are more worried.
“We can’t see them, because we have not just a fence — we have a wall around three-quarters of the kibbutz, so we don’t really see the border,” said Ms. Kissin, 49. “Sometimes I don’t want to know. If the army catches him seconds after he crosses the border, I don’t think I should know, because it really makes the tension more high.”
In Gaza, men who had crossed said Israeli security officials had questioned them, sometimes for hours, about whether Hamas or any other group had sent them, how they had planned their escape, what they intended to do in Israel and, broadly, what was happening back home in the war’s aftermath. When they returned to Gaza, they said, Hamas security officials questioned them, sometimes for hours, about what they had told the Israelis.
Iyad al-Buzom, the spokesman for Gaza’s Interior Ministry, said it had taken “serious measures to prevent border sneaking” since the war and was considering “more harsh procedures and punishments to stop those who think of crossing the fence.” He said officials worried that crossers would be pressured into revealing information to Israeli intelligence upon their arrest, or be hurt as they tried to get to the other side.
Data from the United Nations’ Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs show that Israeli soldiers killed six Palestinians near the fence in 2014, all but one before the war. That was double the number in 2013, but significantly fewer than the average of 22 annually in the previous four years. Thirty-nine Gaza residents were wounded by Israeli fire and tear gas from September through January, the data show, some while protesting or throwing stones, others while trying to cross.
Ateya al-Nabahin, 15, was shot in the neck as he tried to sneak into Israel in November, and he returned home in January after being treated in two Israeli hospitals. “Now, he is lying on his bed like the dead,” Ateya’s brother, Fadi, said in a recent interview. “He cannot walk or even talk like normal people.”
Looking back, Hasan and Salwa al-Zawara’a see plenty of signs that their 20-year-old son, Noor, was planning to cross before he disappeared Oct. 27 from their home in Johor al-Deek, a village next to the Bureij camp.
Three days earlier, his mother recalled, Noor asked for a copy of his identity card. That morning, he changed clothes several times before settling on jeans and a black shirt. He had almost never had a decent night’s sleep since the war, his father said, and he had been asking a sister’s husband who had spent six years in Israeli prison what life was like there.
Now he knows. The younger Mr. Zawara’a, who left school after 11th grade and worked occasionally harvesting olives or in construction, calls once a day from the jail in Beersheba where he is awaiting trial on Feb. 23 for entering Israel illegally.
“The prison is good, because all of them live in a sense of safety,” said Ms. Zawara’a, who has visited her son twice in jail. “After the war, he got really depressed. He started to feel like there is no life and there is no money, no employment.”
“All the people in this place, in each house, you can find someone who tried to cross,” she added. “When I was traveling in the bus, the Israelis were asking us: ‘What’s wrong? Suddenly, the whole neighborhood is coming to us.’ ”
PS The Arabs who work with me are mostly under P.A. Palestinian Authority rule. They simultaneously treasure their jobs and fear that their fellow Arabs will hold them as under suspicion for being too cooperative. Although some do happily pose for pictures when I have my camera out, ouithers have begged me not to take their photos. "They'll kill me; you know who THEY are."


Sammy Finkelman said...

This article is online

But it did not (yet) appear in the printed New York Times in New York. It doesn't even mention that it appeared in the International New York Times, so there may be a plan to print it in the main paper, too. Sometimes articles that aren't precisely timely can appear days later.

It's dated February 17, 2015 1:32 pm and is one of the articles on which they allow, or encourage, comments.

They seem to be almost universally pro-Israel. The Israel-haters didn't see this one.

Sammy Finkelman said...

Here are some articles from last fall about people trying to get out of Gaza into Italy and what happened to them. (many of the passengers were from Gaza. They also come from the Sudan and Egypt itself. People from Gaza get into Egypt using various subterfuges.)

Smugglers nowadays destroy the boats in order to force Italy to take the passengers, and in order not to be on the boat when it is intercepted so as not to be arrested. They probably don't lose anything for passengers who die, except for their reputation compared to competitors and therefore new business, and maybe don't collect full fare for passengers who don't make it.

There is also smuggling of Syrians from Turkey. They are safe in Turkey, but their life is on hold.

Batya said...

It is relatively balanced. At least it doesn't accuse us of destroying Gaza.

Sammy Finkelman said...

Correction - the article I linked to in the first comment is an new article, just written, which elaborates on the article and which probably will not be printed. It was posted online only about two hours ago.

The link to the first article is

It appeared yesterday (Wednesday, Feb 18, 2015) on page A6 in the printed main paper. This one has no comments.

Sammy Finkelman said...

I didn't read that article, my eye being drawn to the article above it:

About possible fear of Israeli leaks about negotiations with Iran.

There's apparently a story circulating that Israel is not being informed about the progress of negotiations because Israel might leak details, but it has been denied both by the Obama Administration and by Israel. It is slight half truth but more probable would be that some people want Israel to be cut out.

Of course the problem is not merely that an Iranian violation would be detectable, it is having a viable plan for what to do if it is detected.

Sammy Finkelman said...

The people living next to Gaza shouldn't think that everybody trying to cross over is an attacker.

The article mentions that if they get arrested (and say they are against Israel, I presume) they get a stipend from the PA in Ramallah, so being in an Israeli prison would give them, and their families, an income.

Batya said...

Sammy, the stipend for prisoners is what many are after and it connects the Ramalla PA to Gaza.

The USA has been keeping Israeli out of the loop for decades. That was was irked Pollard.