Hamas War

Saturday, October 7, 2006

Small World

When I was a teen, and the World's Fair was in nearby Flushing, New York, one of the exhibits had a theme song: "It's a Small World," and that's how I felt when I read It Takes a Sex Scandal in Newsweek.

There's so much rotten in the Israeli Government, criminal investigations against PM Ehud Olmert, Israel's Supreme Court is demanding an independent inquiry not the Winograd Committee, which was appointed by the people they're supposed to be investigating, and now politicians and top army offices are admitting that the decision to have the IDF implement the 2005 disengagement from the Gaza Strip "a serious mistake, for which we are still paying the price."

But what issue has justice moving quickly? It's the Katzav sex scandal, of course.

ps My sources say that there may be something to the charges...

The American scandal involves Rep. Mark Foley, a powerful (male) politician going after young men, pages, teenagers working in Congress. Oh, yes, he's a Republican.
The Foley Scandal is a missile aimed at the heart of the GOP’s most important base constituency: evangelical, Bible-believing Christians, who were already upset with the administration on a host of issues—including spending and immigration.
At the same time in the states, the anti-war forces are simmering and about to explode, and they are mostly Democrats. So it should be pretty interesting there, too. And Israeli politicians shouldn't be so sure that their alliances with the Bush family and other Republicans are such good investments for their futures.

Friday, October 6, 2006

Hard to keep a score card


It's both Erev Shabbat and Erev Succot, and we'll be having most of the kids over, so B"H, I'm busy, too busy for an original post. As you well know, Israeli politicians are very adept at political gymnastics, rather like that newly popular type of "sports warfare" from South America. At least they think that they're graceful, like in capoeira. Of course, I have my own opinions...


With partners like these, who needs an opposition?
By Akiva Eldar

One can assume that when Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni told Yedioth Ahronoth a week ago that it was time to dismantle the illegal outposts, she considered the possibility that someone in Washington would surely call this important declaration by the Israeli foreign minister - who is also the deputy prime minister - to the attention of her friend Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice.

In Washington, some believe that Rice plans to ask during her visit here about the commitments former prime minister Ariel Sharon made to President George W. Bush during their respective first terms. One can also assume Livni is aware that when Ehud Olmert told Haaretz a prime minister could manage well without an agenda, he also had the challenge of dismantling outposts in mind.

Obviously she could not overlook the story about the long hours Kadima Knesset member Otniel Schneller has been spending in the Prime Minister's Office in an effort to "prevent a second Amona," as he puts it. Olmert is willing to pay a hefty price to save himself from another public outcry over a forced outpost evacuation. The orange anti-disengagement camp will surely notice yesterday's statement by Major General Yiftah Ron Tal, former ground operations commander for the Israel Defense Forces, that the involvement of the IDF in the pullout interfered with its performance in the second Lebanon war.

Kadima's quasi-settler thanks the Creator that he has "a prime minister who knows his business and seeks the right solution." He even hopes Olmert will soon invite Danny Tirza, of the settlement Kfar Adumim, for a meeting. Schneller confirms there are talks to bring "Mr. Fence" to the Prime Minister's Office. He is convinced Tirza - accused by the Supreme Court of misleading it on the nature of the fence route - can still contribute to this matter, and can also help advance a solution for the outposts and a dialogue with the orange public. It will be interesting to see the look on the face of Defense Minister Amir Peretz, who objects to the presence of Tirza in his ministry, when he finds him in the Prime Minister's Office instead. Schneller has set aside a major role for Tirza in promoting a new unilateral withdrawal plan he has pitched to Olmert and his Kadima comrades.

According to the plan, the estimated 1,000 people living in outposts will willingly converge into the nearby mother settlements. They will remain there until the outposts are legalized - in other words, until most of the outposts set up without planning procedures or approval are laundered. There are now more than 100 of them. Schneller promises the guiding principle will be as follows: "Israel will fulfill its commitments to the United States - outposts that should not be, will not be."

Who will say which outposts "should be" and which "should not be?" That's what the Sasson report is for - which defined the issue as systematic, government-funded robbery of private land. The mere mention of the name "Sasson" is enough to dampen Schneller's joy. He says a group of legal experts will soon submit a counter-report that will put Sasson's conclusions in a new light.

Schneller carefully says he would gladly "do without" Livni's declaration on the need to dismantle outposts. "When you try to reach arrangements to prevent an argument between Israel and the United States and to spare Israeli society another conflict," he says, "such declarations achieve nothing."

Nineteen months have passed since the Sharon government gave a ministerial commission 90 days to prepare detailed proposals regarding Sasson's recommendations to amend the laws to plug loopholes beckoning land thieves. Over the initial 15 months, which were used to strengthen the outposts, then-justice minister Livni headed the commission. On the eve of last year's Rosh Hashanah, she promised submitting her proposals "after the holidays."

Haim Ramon (Kadima), Livni's successor at the Justice Ministry and in the commission, ordered his own outpost report. The document, which was written by Deputy Attorney General Malchiel Balass, suggests a mechanism for outpost-laundering. Attorney Talia Sasson claims that instead of plugging the loopholes, the Balass document expands them further.

The next minister in line, Meir Sheetrit (Kadima), says he is not committed to the Balass document. As far as he is concerned, if the residents of the outposts want to converge in the approved settlements, ahlan wasahlan - that is, as long as no settler inhabits land taken from a Palestinian and receives government funding for it.

"Even before the Sasson report, and regardless of the Palestinians and the Americans," says Sheetrit, "I said there was no justification for illegal outposts." He promises that under him, the commission will not allow the government to further delay law enforcement in the West Bank.

Sheetrit is not a clean slate in the field of outposts. Seven years ago, when he was finance minister in Netanyahu's government, the settlement division of the World Zionist Federation requested more than $40 million to establish dozens of settlements in the occupied territories. Sheetrit asked the budgets department to prepare a detailed report on each settlement. "They handed me an abysmal report," Sheetrit recalls. "They wanted me to pay half a million shekels for every settlement consisting of one illegal caravan. I informed them the treasury would not release a single cent for illegal settlements."

Incidentally, one of the Sasson Report's central recommendations was to restrain the leeway given to the settlement division, which has been serving as the outposts' main pipeline for years. As with the rest of the recommendations, this one is also gathering dust, and as if to stress the importance he attributes to the division, Olmert appointed his childhood friend Shlomo Gravetz to head it.

With partners like Sheetrit and Livni, Olmert does not need political opponents to pester him over the settlements. And indeed, apart from Minister Ophir Pines-Paz, who already has demanded that Sheetrit summon the ministerial commission immediately, the Labor Party ministers are not worried by the fact that their government is collaborating with the country's biggest illegal project. The party leader, who is also the defense minister and is responsible for the occupied territories, still has not exercised his right to put the issue on the cabinet's agenda.

So what if there's a procedure?

For nearly six years I've been following the ping-pong game the Justice Ministry was playing with the Interior Ministry, until the latter agreed to follow a Supreme Court ruling and draft a procedure regulating local authorities' financial support for public institutions.

The order came following a petition by Attorney Gilad Barnea. As a member of the Jerusalem municipal council, he saw firsthand how politicians, headed by then-mayor Ehud Olmert, were lavishing public funds on educational, cultural, athletic and other institutions, without any criteria to ensure a fair division. The local authorities spend an annual half-billion shekels on institutions.

A document circulated in late July to all local authority heads states, "A local authority may not grant financial support, except by the criteria set here." The document states the local authority's council must approve the proposed criteria no later than the September 1 before the fiscal year in question. No more than two weeks after submitting the budget proposal to the council, the local authority must release a press announcement on how to apply for financial support. The public may submit objections, and the council must discuss each one.

An examination conducted by an involved legal body has shown that none of the local authorities have discussed the criteria so far, and that no public announcements have been made. It is hard to believe the authorities will find the time to accomplish all this in the short time remaining until the beginning of the next fiscal year.

Hundreds of institutions (apart from educational institutions, which received an extension) including day-care centers, theaters and other cultural works, are unaware that on January 1, 2007, they will find their coffers empty. Legally, a local authority head who releases a single shekel without council approval can be slapped with a criminal record.

Thursday, October 5, 2006

Olmert tries plaster on his cracked Kadima

Oct. 4, 2006 23:46 Updated Oct. 5, 2006 0:15
Kadima plans ahead for budget brawl


By GIL HOFFMAN


The heads of Kadima tried to prevent a rebellion in the ranks of the party on Wednesday by arranging a workshop for Kadima MKs on the 2007 state budget with Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's political ally, Finance Minister Avraham Hirchson.

The meeting was organized amid fears that frustrated Kadima backbenchers could prevent the budget from passing by the March deadline and topple their own government. Ministers were asked not to attend the four hours of meetings at the Knesset and the Finance Ministry.

The MKs took turns bashing their own party leadership for failing to keep election promises and abandoning their political agenda. MKs said after the meetings that they were not sure whether they would support the budget and that they did not feel the need to be loyal to party discipline during the vote.

MK Marina Solodkin slammed the government for not finding a solution to Kassam rockets fired near her home town of Ashkelon, the Finance Ministry for not freezing the wages of top government workers and the heads of Kadima for not moving forward with promises to change the governmental system.

MK Amira Dotan questioned the government's lack of long-term strategic planning and its failure to take advantage of the strengths of Kadima MKs. MK David Tal criticized the government's socioeconomic priorities. MK Ronit Tirosh spoke about the party's policies on education.

"This party is being mismanaged and it is only a matter of time before we get more public with our frustration," a Kadima MK said. "We all have our grievances, but the problem is that we have nowhere else to go." A Kadima MK confirmed reports that the MKs have discussed drafting the necessary MKs to leave the party and form an independent faction.

Kadima faction chairman Avigdor Yitzhaki, who has been very critical of Olmert, said the meeting was intended to allow MKs to study the budget and get their problems with the budget addressed long ahead of votes in the Knesset.

MKs have expressed frustration in years past with budget proposals presented to them as a fait accompli that they were forced to vote for or against based on coalition or opposition discipline. Yitzhaki said he hoped other parties in the coalition would make an effort to study the budget in advance of the vote.

"I hope every MK learns about what is in the budget instead of merely spouting slogans," Yitzhaki said. "But the Labor leadership primary is coming up [in May] so I am afraid the Labor MKs will act out of populism and not out of responsibility in hopes of capturing the chairmanship."

Hirchson warned that if the budget were not passed on time, the weakest sectors of the population would be harmed.

It gets "worser and worser"


I don't know if you cook vegetables, but the situation here in Israel is like when you buy a nice big cabbage, (picture credit,) even though you know it's not perfect. Just like these, with the bug holes in the leaves. You hope that it's just a problem with the outside leaves, so you start peeling the leaves off (before soaking and checking again and again.) Sometimes the inner leaves are whole, complete, no sign of infestation, but sometimes the inner leaves look worse than the outer, and there's only one solution--dump it.

Recently when I hear the news I think of that rotten cabbage. It doesn't matter how many leaves we take off, the inside is even more infested with corruption, incompetence and possibly worse.

Every revelation about our government is worse than the previous one. Hat tip to Moshe Burt Amir Peretz isn't qualified to have had been appointed Defense Minister, but it looks like it was all the recent military leaders who got us into this mess. The army is run by "yes men" chasing their tails. If someone finally speaks up, he's sacked.

Ambitious politicians, like Tzachi Hanegbi, are yo-yo-ing as they jockey for positions closer to the right as they ready themselves for the next elections:
"The disengagement neither contributed to the security (of Israel) nor to peace," Hanegbi said in an interview broadcast on Israel Radio.


Now, even if he didn't have "legal problems," how can we trust him after he turncoated and supported Disengagement?

It's bad enough when you find yourself listening to "very personal" conversations as people shout into their cell phones, and in some cases even have the other side on "loud speaker" to reduce radiation in the ear. But to think that the military authorities haven't been paying attention to the obvious that it's easy for "spies" to listen into IDF beepers, cell phones and worse.

And: If everyone agrees that there is a need for a strong NSC, why has this not come about? The state comptroller's report shows serious faults in the way the country is run and decisions are made.

It's time to stop looking for good leaves in this cabbage. Let's cook something else. This isn't the mindset one should have before Zman Simchateinu, Succot, the Festival of Our Joy. This year it begins on Shabbat, the day of the week when we turn off the worries of the mundane. And that is what we'll have to do.

Chag Sameach and Shabbat Shalom

Aliyah l'Regel--On Foot!


During the Succot Holiday, hundreds of thousand of Jews from all over the world come to Jerusalem. For the past three years we've marched from Shiloh to Jerusalem! Though to be exact, the security forces now demand that we ride part of the way. It may take from the purity of the experience, but it's still a wonderful and important annual event.

It's called the Od Avihu Chai March to Jerusalem and is dedicated to the memory of Avihu Keinan, of Shiloh, who was killed in one of those army actions planned according to the safety of the Arabs, rather than to protect our soldiers as much as possible. Ever since Avihu's death, his father, Moshe, has been a the forefront of the movement to challenge and change the false and dangerous "morality" that dominates Israeli policy and thinking.

Since last summer's "nameless war," more and more people are realizing that the IDF doesn't have a clear mission. The false, perverse "morality" and Disengagement have seriously weakened the army. Just this morning it was announced that Maj.-Gen. Yiftah Ron-Tal is being fired from the army to telling the truth: there is a clear link between the IDF's execution of the Disengagement from Gaza and its poor performance during the Lebanon war.

Our march to Jerusalem is not just for Shiloh residents; anyone can join us, and please do!

G-d willing, it will be on Thursday, October 12, Chol Hamoed Succot. For exact schedule and details, including ways to assist, such as donations to cover water and food expenses, please call Orit 0545-649-140.

Wednesday, October 4, 2006

Some Wise Words, but too late





Retiring General: Disengagement Led to IDF Failure in Lebanon
13:57 Oct 04, '06 / 12 Tishrei 5767
by Hillel Fendel


Maj.-Gen. Yiftah Ron-Tal, who retired from the army this year, says there is a clear link between the IDF's execution of the Disengagement from Gaza and its poor performance during the Lebanon war.


Ron-Tal last served as the IDF's Ground Forces Commander. Speaking with Voice of Israel Radio this morning, Ron-Tal said that the army's active participation in the expulsion of the Jews of Gush Katif and northern Shomron last year harmed its readiness for the war in Lebanon. "We are still paying the price of this mistake," he said.

Gen. Ron-Tal, who is still officially in the army, said that the "military and political echelons responsible for the warfare in Lebanon should take responsibility for the failure." Asked if he means that Olmert and Halutz should resign, he said, "That is usually what taking responsibility means."

"In June and July of 2005," Ron-Tal said, "the army was sufficiently ready to defeat Hizbullah - but the army dedicated most of its time to training for the Disengagement, at the expense of training [for war]. The army was not at a level that it could not fight, but during the first few days of warfare they had to remove rust... Was the army supposed to deal with Disengagement? It's not the army's job to expel Jews, which was something that was not in consensus, and as a people's army, it should not have had to do this."

In answer to a question, he said he does not intend to enter politics. Speaking earlier with the Kfar Chabad magazine, Ron-Tal said that for a country to volunteer to uproot its own communities is "an act of suicide... I still cannot understand how Israel gave up parts of its land so willingly and enthusiastically, and how it turned the residents who are so attached to the Land into criminals, instead of admiring their struggle to preserve the Jewish character of the State."

Ron-Tal said earlier this year that when he was faced with the choice of either resigning from the army or carrying out Disengagement orders, he deliberated, but chose the latter.

MK Uri Ariel, whip of the Knesset's National Union-National Religious Party faction, said that Ron-Tal's remarks against the army's participation in the Disengagement "reflect the opinion of most of the senior officers. The problem is that they don't stand firm in their position and did not say these things when it mattered." MK Ariel called on other IDF officers to reveal the extent of their opposition to the Disengagement.

IDF Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen. Dan Halutz has summoned Gen. Ron-Tal for a "clarification" of his remarks. The IDF Spokesman said that it is "not appropriate for an officer on retirement leave who is receiving an army salary to express criticism of the State of Israel's political echelons. The matter is even more grave in light of the fact that Gen. Ron-Tal was a member of the IDF General Staff and was a partner to all the processes and decisions, including the Disengagement plan."

MK Aryeh Eldad (National Union) said that Gen. Ron-Tal is correct in linking between the army's participation in the expulsion and its failure in the recent war. "The army wasted 4.5 million work days in order to expel 9,000 Jews from their homes," Eldad said, "and the Chief of Staff gave out certificates of excellence to the units that excelled in the expulsion. This is not the way to defeat Arabs."

MK Tzvi Hendel, also of the National Union, was one of the thousands of Jews expelled from their homes in Gush Katif last year. He heard Ron-Tal's remarks with bitterness, saying, "It's too bad that he did not have the courage to say this in real-time, though at least now he got up the strength to say what most of the General Staff thinks."

Hendel added, "During the expulsion from Gush Katif, it was specifically those who wore the IDF uniform who were obligated to warn the entire public against this dangerous and corrupt act, in order to save the IDF - which is precious to the entire public - from corruption and destruction."




The Sputnik!






I'm very glad that I had started school before the Sputnik was launched by the USSR! The United States went into total panic and hysteria. We weren't NUMBER ONE, NUMERO UNO. We were second at best!

The experts decided that the problem was with our outdated educational methods, especially mathematics. In response and total desperation, the most creative minds in education invented "new math." And since then, math has gotten newer and newer until it has reached today's level, when kids need a new cellphone to calculate what I can do in my head.

America raced to beat the Russians, while my friends and I raced to finish school.

The US sent its first "man in space," Alan Shepard, the same day I went with the rest of the Sixth Graders of PS 46 to tour Junior High 74. I guess we didn't see a "typical day," since the entire school was listening to the historic news on the radio.

Now back to math...

The United States never quite caught up, even though American kids have more computers and more fun learning math. Teachers have also been forced to learn more and more methods, while the US engineering graduate schools are filling with foreign-trained students who were deprived of all the modern and new math.

One shouldn't forget that the developers of the Sputnik were taught math in a very old-fashioned way, so it didn't really make sense for the Americans to distance math education from the basics.

And talking of basics for learning math, after the ten fingers, nothing gives a better grounding than a traditional Abacus.

a "Shehechiyanu" for AbbaGav


Sing along with the chazan, Belgium Cantor Areyh Braun, because AbbaGav has a new look, a new address and is celebrating by hosting the the 88th Havel Havelim!

That's quite a Mezuza for the new "home."

MAZAL TOV!

ps I'm hosting the next one, just after Simchat Torah (Israel time), G-d willing, and after that there's the Kosher Cooking Carnival. So Please send the posts in. If you see something for either carnival, please send me the link. Send to shilohmuse at yahoo dot com or via blog carnival.

Tuesday, October 3, 2006

Governments, all the same?

Many of us aren't very shocked that Israel's President Katzav is embroiled in a sex scandal. It's a rare world leader/politician without a similar story; though in most cases the stories have been hidden from public view. Clinton survived his Monica, which could be best told in comicbook form. JFK's women were more numerous but more discreet, and FDR had a very serious extra-marital relationship. A generation ago, Israel's Moshe Dayan was excused for his flings and Bibi Netanyahu, by admitting indiscretions, isn't paying the heavy price Katzav is. Of course, it may just be a conspiracy against Katzav, but who knows? Could it just be part of the psychological profile of a politician to have that sort of "impulsively problem?"

Unfortunately, it's not just sex which the politicians get wrong. Read the following two articles about how governments are really run and crucial decisions made. Honestly, I find it rather frightening. These are the people who make our life, death and survival decisions. These are the people who send our sons (and daughters) into war.

First from Newsweek:
"State of Denial"
It was Bush's decision. But Rumsfeld drove the dynamic on Iraq. How the SecDef blew it. An exclusive excerpt.


Next from the Jerusalem Post:
A barometer for Dan Halutz
Blamed by the Agranat Commission for the IDF's unreadiness in the Yom Kippur War, Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen. David Elazar was drummed out of the army. Two years later, at age 51, still stunned by the onus that had been placed on him, he died of a heart attack.

Monday, October 2, 2006

Everything closed down for Yom Kippur, except the Arab's rocket launchers

In Israel, Yom Kippur is not the day to go shopping, take a bus or go to the movies. Everything closes down for close to 30 hours,, giving people a chance to eat, then fast 25 hours and finally eat again. Ruthie Blum wrote about the kids who ride bikes in the middle of the street in relative safety.

But Yom Kippur wasn't just a day of quiet prayer, reflections, fasting and cycling in the south. 2 Qassam rockets fired at Sderot Monday (Yom Kippur.)

Sunday, October 1, 2006

EXCUSE ME!

What a lot of nerve!

This New York Times Editorial presses all the wrong buttons!
With Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice traveling to the region next week, Mr. Bush should give her an explicit mandate to press Israel, and not just the Palestinians, for real compromises.

Israel and "the Palestinians (sic)" aren't a couple of miss-behaving children who need a "pop" by their parents or teachers.

The true situation is that the Arabs are terrorists trying to destroy the State of Israel.

On Friday, Tens of thousands of Hamas supporters held a peaceful rally in Gaza to denounce the state of Israel and declare that they would never recognize its right to exist.

By refusing to take a good look and listen to what the Arabs are saying, the US and the international media, like the NYT are endangering the world.