Hamas War

Tuesday, September 12, 2006

It's a matter of priorities


In a very modern interpretation of
אם אין אני לי, מי לי; וכשאני לעצמי, מה אני; ואם לא עכשיו, אימתי.פרקי אבות, פרק א, משנה יד
"Im ein ani li, mi li; uchshe'ani le'atzmi, ma ani; ve'im lo achshav, eymatay?" -- Ethics of the Fathers, Chapter 1, Episode 14
Translation: "If I am not to myself, who will be? And when I am [only] to myself, who am I? And if not now, when?"

the Israeli Cabinet will probably pass the budget, even though it contradicts most, if not all, of the coalition agreement and the parties' economic and social platforms.


Here are a few excerpts from the Basic Guidelines of the 31st Government of Israel, 4 May 2006, translated from Hebrew:
4. The Government will act to narrow social gaps and will formulate a detailed plan to battle against social distress and will work to improve the public health system in general and amend the components of the health basket in particular. Foundations will be laid to provide equal opportunities for all its citizens, regardless of differences in race, religion or sex.

5. The Government will fight corruption and immorality in all areas of life, and, first and foremost, in government institutions and the public administration.

7. The Government will fight crime and violence and will do its utmost to protect the personal security of Israel’s residents.

10. Israel will continue to act determinedly in order to guarantee the security of its citizens and residents in and outside of Israel, against terror organizations threatening to harm them.

11. Israel will continue to act, anywhere and anytime, in order to foil, disrupt and prevent terror attacks against its citizens or residents.

13. The Government considers the build-up of its military and security force and the preservation of Israel’s deterrence capabilities against all enemies to be an essential component, without which the country’s integrity, the safety of its citizens and economic prosperity cannot be preserved.

24. During its tenure, the Government will determine a target to be reached gradually, to raise and fix the minimum wage to NIS 4,600 ($1,000). To this end, and following an agreement between the coordinating bureau of the financial organizations and the New General Labor Union, the minimum wage will be raised in the first stage by an overall rate of NIS 500, in two phases: first – by half the amount during the present budgetary year, no later than June 1, 2006; and second – by half the amount during 2007 (totaling NIS 125 on April 1, 2007 and NIS 125 on June 1, 2007).

26. The Government will act immediately to build a system of efficient and appropriate enforcement of labor laws, including the minimum wage law, in a manner that will ensure compliance with the terms of labor laws in every field of the economy.

34. The Government will act to advance the rights of the aged and pensioners.

39. ...
The Government will ensure accessibility to higher education, in a way that assures equal opportunities in education. This equality will be ensured, inter alia, by determining appropriate tuition, providing a subsidized loan system for students who are unable to fund their studies, integrating students into national projects to reduce illiteracy and social gaps. The Government will further implement a funding plan for higher education, in the spirit of the model which was successfully implemented in Australia.


My gut feeling is that the cabinet members will do everything they can to stay in business. New elections are the last things they want, since many have no chance of being re-elected. And if elections are held soon, Olmert's chances of forming the next government are anorexic at best. If they reject the budget proposal, it will be a green light to vote against it for those wavering Knesset Members, who aren't in the cabinet.

I included the pictures, so you can visualize the people who are making such fateful decisions for the State of Israel.

And if you haven't yet heard, new corruption charges are being made against Olmert.

picture and cabinet list credit

The Backpedaling Prime Minister



As Caroline Glick has reminded us
We should recall that Olmert stated at the outset of the war that Israel's goals were to secure Regev and Goldwasser's unconditional release, disarm Hizbullah, and remove its fighters from the border. The nation fully supported all of these goals - none of which was achieved…By going to war, Israel placed the initiative for freeing the soldiers in its own hands. By agreeing to the cease-fire without first securing their release, Olmert effectively handed the power to determine their fate to Hizbullah. But rather than acknowledge his failure, Olmert attacks the public for having believed him.

So here’s the first backpedal – none of the stated goals of the war were achieved, which means we should still be at war – except our Prime Minister backpedaled!

Then, we weren’t going to withdraw our troops until the entire UNIFIL troops were in place, AND we received our captives back. But, as Caroline continues…
The government's dereliction of duty regarding the IDF captives is of course but one component of its overall failure in managing the war and the cease-fire in Lebanon. Other components are the result of the government's capitulation to all UN and European demands and positions. These include Israel's acceptance of the participation of soldiers from hostile states in the UNIFIL force, and its resignation to the assertion that UNIFIL forces will not disarm Hizbullah, will not patrol the Lebanon-Syria border to enforce an arms embargo against Hizbullah, and will not force Hizbullah fighters to abandon their positions in southern Lebanon.

Then,
Israel Harel of Ha'aretz tells us,
Israel, a regional power in its own eyes that was fighting a small guerrilla outfit, did not have the power, sense, or willpower to condition the cease-fire on the release of the soldiers, or at least to demand their hand-over to a third party that could guarantee their welfare. Our victory was so great that we insisted that a force consisting of 15,000 UN soldiers, including ones from "friendly states" such as Malaysia and Indonesia - and France, of course - would serve as a buffer between us and the enemy that we routed.

And what about the blockade, which was to insure that the captive soldiers were not taken out of Lebanon to Iran or elsewhere, and that no more weaponry would reach Hizbullah?

´Lifting the Lebanon Blockade Means Abandoning the Captives´
"So says Gen. (ret.) Uzi Dayan, head of the Return the Captives task force."

And from a
Jerusalem Post editorial:
The air and sea blockade of Lebanon, lifted by Israel at 6 p.m. yesterday, was supposed to be in place until all international forces had arrived and Israel had at least received information regarding its kidnapped soldiers in Lebanon. Only about one-fifth of the planned international forces is in place, there is no mechanism to secure the Lebanese-Syrian border and Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev not only remain captive, but the government has received no confirmation regarding their condition. Why, then, was the blockade lifted? Defense Minister Amir Peretz said it was lifted because the US asked Israel to lift it.

So he backpedaled on the troop withdrawal, the makeup of the UNIFIL contingent, and the blockade. As if that wasn’t enough, what about the release of Gilead Shalit? Wasn’t any meeting with Abu Mazen [Abbas] supposed to be only after he was released?

Olmert told reporters that he plans to meet with PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) in the near future. Though just last week he said he would not meet with Abbas before captive soldier Gilad Shalit is released, he no longer has set any preconditions for such a meeting.

Hmmm…more backpedaling, it seems.

But don’t worry, he even backpedaled on the “Hitkansut/Convergence” plan:
Olmert expressed his willingness and intention to advance the Quartet's Road Map Plan between Israel and the PA. He announced that the Realignment Plan, his main election campaign platform, was no longer relevant. The Road Map plan, initiated in 2002, calls for an end to terrorism, an end to Israel's settlement activity, and the formation of a Palestinian state. Ex-Prime Minister Ariel Sharon said that the U.S. guaranteed that Israel could retain major settlement blocs in the Shomron, but this has not been borne out by the relevant documents. The plan has not yet made it to its first step.

Why has all this happened? – Perhaps
Sarah Honig has the answer:
Any normal country - and Israel most categorically isn't normal - would simply destroy towns and villages that serve as rocket bases against its civilians. Bint Jbail and Maroun el-Ras shouldn't have been left standing. That's what America would do, or Russia, Britain and most undoubtedly duplicitous France. One would shudder to think how China would react. But Israel is different.The agent of our malady - that potent pathogen undermining our continued survival - is our excessive care about the world's opinion of us, while the world doesn't give a hoot about Israel's fate (and that's resorting to gross understatement). It's a chronic Jewish syndrome now turned into a full-blown existential hazard to the state and its people. Until we recognize, admit and address what can only be defined as a suicidal aberration, our self-preservation is most definitely not guaranteed.

Monday, September 11, 2006

9-11 all over



picture credits

I didn't think I was going to write about 9-11, but then I read The Beak Speaks: There are no atheists in Foxholes and I felt the need.

It looked very different here in Israel, especially from my perspective. First of all, my aliyah pre-dated the Twin Towers, so they weren't part of the New York of my memories. Actually I was never there. Even as a New Yorker, all those decades ago, I almost never went further downtown than 14th Street. My Manhattan, New York went from 14th Street to 60th, or from the old OU-NCSY office on 5th Avenue and 14th Street until Bloomingdales, on Lexington and 60th. To the west I went as far as Penn Station, 7th Avenue and 33rd Street. My chief focus was 34-5th Streets, between Madison and Lexington, when I studied at Stern College for two years.

Even more important is the fact that I am a terror survivor. Five and a half years before 9-11, while standing at the French Hill bus stop, waiting for a ride or bus home, a terrorist, armed with a car rammed into us. He murdered one and injured quite a few. I was the least injured. He knocked me over and ran over my foot.

Thank G-d, I wore soft shoes, so no bones were broken, but the soft-tissue damage took over six months to heal. And of course, after an experience like that one is never the same. The neighbor who was standing next to me and witnessed it and heard my scream as I was knocked down is probably even more traumatized. Her parents refer to me as "the person who saved" their daughter, feeling that if I hadn't been there, he would have rammed into her doing even more damage.

The Arab terrorists attack civilians in Israel a lot more frequently than in the states. I expected the understanding that we have the same enemies, but I never heard that, especially soon after 9-11. Americans acted like the only truly dangerous terrorists were the ones who attacked them. They, the United States, are empowered to do everything to destroy their terrorists, but Israel has to tolerate "our" terrorism.

I find this sentiment and philosophy unforgivable and dangerous. Arab Moslem terrorism is the same, with the same mother and father, whether it happens in the Pentagon or the Dolphinarium, whether the victims are Jews, Christian, Hindus, Buddhists, Moslems or atheists.

Terrorism will never be destroyed until it is understood that they are all connected. The so-called Palestinians endanger world peace, and the world encourages them.

Per capita Israel has lost more innocent civilians that the United States, and don't forget that some of the Israeli terror victims also held American citizenship.
We must unite to destroy Arab Moslem terrorism, if not, nothing was learned from the tragedy, and that's the greatest tragedy of all.

Here's someone who concurs with what you heard here first!

Awhile ago the Founder and First Lady of this blog, Batya, expressed herself as being totally unimpressed and underwhelmed by the current touted Savior of Israel's Right, former IDF Chief of Staff Moshe "Boogey" Ya'alon. Over at Manhigut Yehudit, Shmuel Sackett gets it right. BTW, if you want a candidate for Mashiach (and I doubt that you need to have one until he presents himself), read the Rambam's Hilchot Melachim. There he says that the provisional choice need not do miracles, but must be one who follows Torah and encourages other Jews to do so and fights the wars of Hashem. Nowhere does it say he has to fight on a battlefield. He could be, say, in intelligence. (Are you getting it?) Rabbi Akiva chose a person who was not a great Torah scholar, but a leader in battle who supported Torah observance. The gemara in Sanhedrin, Perek Helek, mentions that Mashiach is in chains at the gates of Rome. If Rome today is America, how about Jonathan Pollard? His actions to provide Israel with intelligence information got him locked up and since then he has become a dedicated follower of Torah who considers Rav Mordechai Eliahu as his rav. He keeps Torah and mitzvot as best he can in the prison where he is incarcerated. From time to time he sends out a pronouncement to Jews to be strong in Torah and proud as both individuals and as a nation. I'm not saying this dogmatically (no singing of Yechi please), but just showing you the contrast between someone like him and someone like Bibi or Boogey.

Sunday, September 10, 2006

Exile by any other name is just as Evil


Whether it's called התכנסות, "Hitcansut," or Convergence, or Disengagement it's all the same. And just because Olmert has decided it's "bad business" to use the term "Hitcansut," or "Convergence" does not mean that he has changed plans.

He's only changing labels, like those magicians with their "Sleight of Hand" technique. Olmert and gang are prepared to keep changing those labels until we're dizzy.

So I wasn't surprised this morning to see staring at me on the computer screen. Olmert Pushing Roadmap Plan
Blair arrived in Jerusalem late Sabbath afternoon, meeting with Mr. Olmert to hear what steps are being taken by Israel towards the implementation of the UN-brokered ceasefire in Lebanon, UN Resolution 1701.


It should have been obvious. Why else was Blair here on Shabbat? Blair is also under pressure to resign. So now Olmert's using the Roadmap label. It is also a plan demanding the destruction of Jewish communities and the ghettoization, apartheid of Jewish life in Israel.

The simplest way of proving that he hasn't changed policy is that the ghetto walls are still going up. None of the government spokespersons have said anything about pulling them down.

We have to fight the plan, not the labels.

We have to fight for the right for Jews to live in the Entire Land of Israel without restrictions!






picture credit, Yad Veshem
According to all the news reports, 25-30,000 people attended last night's massive rally demanding: “State Commission of Inquiry Now!”

It was sponsored by a coalition of groups.

Tens of thousands gathered Saturday night in Rabin Square in Tel Aviv to support a call for a state investigation into the war.
Speakers at the protest were to include former education minister Yossi Sarid (Meretz) and former defense minister Moshe Arens (Likud).

"We must do soul-searching, examine ourselves and 'purify the camp,'" Movement for Quality Government Chairman Eliad Shraga told the protesters, setting the tone for a series of angry speakers.

MQG Chairman Eliad Shraga appealed to the all of the nation to join the rally, which contained people from all sides of the political spectrum. One of the speakers at the rally was former Meretz chairman and minister Yossi Sarid. His presence, said Shraga, was an answer to "all those people (primarily from the Peace Now movement) who portrayed this protest as something orange."

Oh, yes, why wasn't I there?
The biggest reason was a simple one, no transportation from Shiloh to Tel Aviv on a Saturday night. Unlike the demonstrations sponsored by Moetzet YESHA, which always took into account that without buses, nobody could make it, this one was geared towards those with private transportation, or in the Tel Aviv area, or those who traveled on Shabbat.
Another thing was that they didn't want it to look like a YESHA demonstration. As you can see in the quotation from Eliad Shraga, he wanted it to be clear that even Peace Now supporters want a State Commission of Inquiry. Look at the pictures here, which I didn't succeed in posting. For example, the sign, which says: "Olmert and Chalutz--Go Home," doesn't have the ב"ה in the right upper corner, which is part of the "template" for religious Jews.
I'm glad that the turn-out was good.

Saturday, September 9, 2006

Fantastic JPost Editorial!

I thought I was hallucinating when I read this very sensible, intelligent editorial in Friday's Jerusalem Post. The entire text will be copied for you to read, but first there was something else, not directly about Israel, in the NY Times. One of the serious and problematic issues in Israeli Government is the method for choosing judges. Apparently, there are problems in New York, too.

Now, I'll get the editorial up quickly, before my husband returns and wants his "turn" on the computer!


The air and sea blockade of Lebanon, lifted by Israel at 6 p.m. yesterday, was supposed to be in place until all international forces had arrived and Israel had at least received information regarding its kidnapped soldiers in Lebanon. Only about one-fifth of the planned international forces is in place, there is no mechanism to secure the Lebanese-Syrian border and Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev not only remain captive, but the government has received no confirmation regarding their condition.

Why, then, was the blockade lifted?

Defense Minister Amir Peretz said it was lifted because the US asked Israel to lift it. But why would the US ask Israel to ignore the gaping holes in the implementation of UN Security Council Resolution 1701? And why would Israel meekly capitulate on a position so solidly grounded in its national interest and the supposed will and objectives of the international community?

Israel has just fought a war to destroy Hizbullah. It failed in that objective, but it potentially achieved something that could justify the war's great costs: an international commitment and determination to, if not fully disarm, at least prevent the rearming of Hizbullah.

The participation of German, Italian, French, Turkish and other forces in taking Israel's place in preventing arms smuggling by sea and via Beirut's airport, or in supporting the deployment of Lebanese forces in southern Lebanon, is a significant accomplishment. But just as it is fruitless to lock three out of four doors of a car, all this effort will be for naught if the Lebanese-Syrian border remains open for smuggling business.

Resolution 1701 sought to close this route - by which Hizbullah had built an enormous arsenal, courtesy of Syria and Iran - on two levels: first by imposing an international embargo against weaponry going to anyone but the Lebanese army, and second by enforcing that embargo at the Lebanese-Syrian border. To this end, Resolution 1701 explicitly authorized UNIFIL to help Lebanon secure this border, if Lebanon so requested.

It is hard to conceive of a more important provision of Resolution 1701 than the monitoring of the nine road crossings between Syria and Lebanon. Though the border as a whole is long, mountainous, largely unpatrolled and even unmarked, it would be very difficult to smuggle large missiles across it except through the road crossings.

As Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev told The New York Times on Wednesday, "The land border with Syria is the wild card and the real test of the arms embargo. We're hopeful we'll see Lebanese forces augmented by international forces there on the border enforcing the arms embargo. It would be very nice to believe Syria would change its policies, but we'd like a verification process."

But what hope is there that this will happen when Secretary-General Kofi Annan himself, speaking in Beirut on his recent visit, contradicted Resolution 1701 and denied that helping Lebanon secure that border was part of UNIFIL's mandate?

According to an unnamed Israeli official, Israel has an "understanding" that such a UNIFIL deployment will happen. This sounds ominously like the understanding Israel had that the Lebanese army would deploy in the south when Israel withdrew unilaterally in 2000. Given the record, Israel has no basis to trust the UN or Lebanon, absent concrete leverage to ensure that supposed commitments will not become a dead letter, like UN Resolution 1559 requiring the disarming of Hizbullah.

By lifting the air and sea blockade, Israel ceded its primary leverage. Though Israel claims the right to enforce a smuggling embargo from the air, this is unrealistic, given the impossibility of distinguishing between legitimate commerce and a "civilian" truck carrying missiles. The IDF believes that it is impossible to enforce an embargo from afar, which was a primary reason for its opposition to lifting the embargo.

The US and Israel should have turned the responsibility for lifting Israel's blockade back on to Lebanon and the UN, by insisting that a mechanism be put in place to at least prevent the smuggling of weaponry through official border crossings. Yet even now, after that opportunity has been squandered, the responsibility remains on Israel and the international community to achieve this purpose. Now that its primary leverage on enforcing the embargo and returning the kidnapped soldiers has been given up, it is hard to see how the government can prevent the rearming of Hizbullah. But it is vital.

Friday, September 8, 2006

Oy, The Public

Democracy is no better than the people who vote. At least polls are just "trial runs." This last IMRA poll shows how little the public thinks about the consequences.

On one hand the vast majority of those who answered said that the proposed budget is bad.
From what you have heard, is the State budget for 2007 good or bad on a
social-welfare standpoint?
Good 7.6% Bad 70.3% Neither 9.2% Other 12.9%


But not approving the budget can make the government fall, needing new elections. They don't want new elections.
In light of the situation, should Knesset elections be advanced?
Yes 40.9% No 53.8% Other 5.3%


They want Labor to leave the government over the budget.
If the State budget for 2007 is approved in the Knesset in accordance withy
the current Ministry of Finance proposal, should the Labor Party leave the
government because of it?
Yes 52.4% No 27.6% Other 20.0%
Voted Labor: Yes 35.4% No 42.6% Other 22.0%

But they want more parties to join the government.
Do you support or oppose the initiative to form an emergency government?
Support 50.2% Oppose 40.5% Other 9.3%
Voted Kadima: Support 39.0% Oppose 52.6% Other 8.4%

Shabbat is getting closer, Baruch Hashem, so I can stop this nonsensical report of public opinion.

Budget-Cutting

Israel's annual budget crisis has the pundits in suspense. Will the government fall or not? This latest budget has no real supporters. Coalition partners contend that it violates all agreements. The Labor Party will discuss it today. They aren't the only coalition party who opposes it; the Pensioners Party campaigned for better pensions, and the budget goes against its principles.

But this is politics, not principles. The politicians are happy with their perks. Consider how many ministers there are, 25! And they already have their Knesset salaries. It's a good business, nu? There are families in this country, with kids, who have to live on less than those ministers get as "clothing allowance."

The United States, which is a much larger country, has a smaller Cabinet, and it isn't filled with senators and congressmen:

The Cabinet includes the Vice President and the heads of 15 executive departments-the Secretaries of Agriculture, Commerce, Defense, Education, Energy, Health and Human Services, Homeland Security, Housing and Urban Development, Interior, Labor, State, Transportation, Treasury, and Veterans Affairs, and the Attorney General. Under President George W. Bush, Cabinet-level rank also has been accorded to the Administrator, Environmental Protection Agency; Director, Office of Management and Budget; the Director, National Drug Control Policy; and the U.S. Trade Representative.

Now, if there's a need for reducing Israeli national expenses, I'd dump the Cabinet. Since it's filled with Knesset Members, who have parallel committees, the committees can do the job of the ministries. Why duplicate things?

If there's a need for tightening belts, let it start with those who can afford suits.

Shabbat Shalom u'Mevorach

Thursday, September 7, 2006

It Would be Funny if it Weren't so Sad...


You really need a sense of humor to live in Israel. You know that there is a rally in Kikar Rabin [Tel Aviv] on 8:45 PM Saturday night -- to call for a committee of inquiry about the mishandling of the war.

It now turns out that Eliad Shraga, [link in Hebrew] the red-haired lawyer who runs the "Movement for Quality Government", has suddenly invited -- guess who? OLMERT!! -- to speak at the rally, which is sort of like inviting someone from the Chevra Kadisha [Burial Society] to speak at a conference for cancer patients.

Shraga has indicated that in a democracy, Olmert is entitled to speak. Well of course he is -- and similarly, it is the democratic privilege of anyone who is going to the rally, to just slip a whistle into his pocket so that s/he can exercise her or his freedom of expression while Olmert speaks (if he actually does).

So please -- BRING A WHISTLE. If you don't have one, bring a cooking pot and a big spoon.


PS - The Israeli Broadcasting Authority was forced [after being taken to the "Supreme Court"] to allow the organizers of the rally to publicize it on Israeli Radio, now there's a real democracy for ya!

Opposition Leader?


During the last Israeli Elections, Avigdor Lieberman campaigned well and hard. photo credit It'll take more than prayers to get what he wants.

He's a powerful man. A few years ago, when wandering around Kikar Zion, the downtown "square" in Jerusalem, I suddenly felt a stare. I looked around and noticed Lieberman standing just outside "Marcel's," the popular barbershop. He was "taking in" the crowds. As a teacher, I really envy that talent. He's the type who can walk into a noisy crowded room, and suddenly, without doing "anything," all the attention's on him.

The world is starting to take notice, and they should. Even Newsweek has him featured in a comprehensive interview, a privilege rarely given to anybody to the right of Ehud Olmert.

Lieberman is a decade younger than Bibi Netanyahu. His "other language" is Russian rather than English. Their styles are very different; though I have a feeling that their actual policies, especially under pressure, are the same. Even though I wish there was more choice, it seems like there isn't anyone besides those two jostling for national leadership.

At this point I couldn't say which I prefer. Is anybody ready to vote?