Tuesday, August 29, 2017

Rebels in the Holy Land, The Story of Mazkeret Batya

This is crossposted on Israel Blogger as, Mazkeret Batya Founders were Real Pioneers.

Rebels in the Holy Land - Mazkeret Batya - An Early Battleground for the Soul of Israel may not be hot off the press, but I'm glad I was given the book to review.

The fascinating story of the early years of the town Mazkeret Batya is told to us by Sam Finkel in Rebels in the Holy Land. Not only did I learn the history of that very special town, but I discovered so much of what I had never known about the history of settlement in the Land of Israel before Herzl and Zionism.

Finkel begins his tale in Europe with a visionary Jewish writer named  Yechiel Brill, who was the prime mover for the enterprise of bringing ten simple Jewish farmers from Europe to build a farming community in the Holy Land.  Brill was a journalist who taught himself Hebrew and then established a Hebrew language newspaper, Levanon. Just that could put him in History Books, but he made history, too. He did the fundraising, recruiting, organizing, mentoring and more for the establishment of Mazkeret Batya, originally called Ekron.

As I read  Rebels in the Holy Land, I felt that I was reading an adventure story, a mystery. This is not a dry history book. The writing is clear, and as you can see the illustrations and graphics are phenomenal, without a doubt. It can almost qualify as a "coffee table book," because you can just pick it up, open randomly and read a page or two. Each section can stand on its own.

The farmers who agreed to Brill's visionary idea of a Jewish farming community in the Land of Israel were simple people. They were neither intellectuals nor wealthy, but they were sincerely Gd fearing. They insisted on following the Torah Laws and the rabbis, even when their financial supporter, Baron Edmond de Rothschild, and his administrators demanded otherwise. Reading of the battle of wills that went on during their first Shmitta, Sabbatical Year, was painful for me. The farmers of Ekron, which had been renamed Mazkeret Batya by the Baron in memory of his mother, feared and respected Gd more than their wealthy patron and his anti-religious administrators.

Those of you who are more knowledgeable about that era in history may not be all that surprised, but for me Rebels in the Holy Land was full of new discoveries.

I highly recommend Rebels in the Holy Land for yourself and as gifts for others of all ages. It's the most readable history book I've ever come across.


  • ITEM #: 6710
  • Dimensions: 6x9
  • ISBN: 978-1-59826-861-4
  • Weight: 2.8400 lbs
  • Binding: Hard Cover / 471 pages
  • Published by: Distributed by Feldheim


Mr. Cohen said...

There are many good Jewish books that
do not receive the numbers of readers
that they deserve.

Here is just one that comes to mind:

JEWS FOR NOTHING by Dov Aharoni Fisch,
published by Feldheim in year 1984 CE.

How to Convict the New York Times
of Unfair Bias Against Israel:


Why Israel’s 1967 Borders are Undefendable:


How intermarriage harms Jewish
sovereignty over the Land of Israel


Batya said...

As you know, I get books to review. Some reviews appear here and the others on my blog A Jewish Grandmother. It depends on subject/genre.

Neshama said...

Speaking of immigrants, I think the iAID (Israelis) should bring all the Jews from Houston to Israel, and let them live in an absorption center, being given food and clothing to live here and wait out the rebuilding of Houston, and then to decide whether they want to return or stay!

Batya said...

2 things
1- Who says that Jews (however you define the term) want to move to Israel?
2- Why do you think there are still absorption centers?